Aesthetica Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner - Waterproof, Long-lasting, Vegan, Jet Black - 0.5oz

I like the felt tip rather than brush tip (that always seems to get splayed out and funky). It does not flake nor does it make rings under my eyes. I have tried a LOT of liquid liners. This is in the top 3. I will purchase again. I'm not sure it's 100 percent waterproof, but the portion that comes off doesn't appear to smudge or flake (after crying or swimming). It just looks like I lost the 'wings' from my original application.
Read more

I'm no makeup expert, in fact far from it. I liked this eyeliner very much. The tip is flexible but also firm, just the right amount of light pressure to achieve different looks. It is even suitable for the under lash line/water line application. I like that this holds up a long time, especially over shimmery eye shadow, an area where other eyeliners fall short. I haven't tried swimming to test out the waterproof but I did rub plain water over my eyes and nothing smudged. I have already ordered for my daughter and will reorder when I run out. Great product and price
Read more

I have been searching for a new liquid liner for ages. This one is fabulous! I do extreme makeup, and needed something that would be dark, matt, and last all day. This checks every box! I've been using it for about a month now, and it is still just as dark and liquid as the day I bought it. It does take a couple extra seconds to dry (so keep your eyes closed after applying), but it's totally worth it for the long-lasting wear I get from it. Thanks for the great liner!
Read more

Wow! I bought this eyeliner when my Sephora one ran out and now I'm not sure I'll go back. This eyeliner is a better price, easier to maneuver because of the pen style and it doesn't need to be redipped, and lasts forEVER. When I first got it, I did a doodle on my hand to see how it handled, and that doodle lasted 48 hours and a shower before it faded completely. It didn't smudge, flake, or rub off on anything else, but still comes off easily with makeup remover. I'm sold!
Read more

This photo is Kat Von D Tattoo Liner (it's a bit aged compared to the aesthetica, so that could be why-- top) VS Aesthetica (bottom) compared by the thinnest I can get it to the thickest I can get it. I think the photo really speaks to its pigmentation and the fact that it can even hold a candle to the ultra thin name brand. The only thing I can say that's a bit saddening is the formula, because it's so quick drying, doesn't like when you try to add more to it-- making it not the best for building. However, that can really just be avoided if you make sure to get everything really nice while it's still drying, by doing the triangle method.
Read more